Tenth Circuit Holds That Two-and-One-Half Years and Two-and-One-Half Million Dollars Do Not Constitute Prejudice

In BSC Holding, Inc. et al. v. Lexington Ins. Co., — Fed.Appx. –, 2014 WL 929194 (10th Cir., March 11, 2014), the Tenth Circuit recently underscored  how difficult it can be for an insurer to demonstrate prejudice as a result of late notice.  The District of Kansas had granted summary judgment to Lexington, but the Court of Appeals reversed and sent the matter back to the lower court, holding that “substantial prejudice” had not been shown despite the fact that the policyholder had waited two-and-one-half years to notify the carrier and had spent $2.5 million dollars before doing so.

Lyons Salt Company owned a salt mine in Kansas.  In January 2008, mine workers detected an inflow of water into the mine, and the insured set out to determine the cause and to devise a solution.  In April 2010, following an extensive investigation by geotechnical experts and engineers, the inflow was attributed to an improperly sealed oil well that was deforming overlying shale formations.  The experts told Lyons that the situation was “dire”  and that a quick remedy was required, and the insured immediately set about constructing a specially-designed concrete bulkhead to seal off part of the mine.

shutterstock_95321077Lyons notified Lexington of the water inflow in July 2010, after it had already spent $2.5 million on the problem.  The insured sought coverage under six Lexington policies of “all risk” property insurance issued between March 2004 and April 2010.  Suit was filed in the Spring of 2011 after Lexington refused to commit to reimbursement.  The sworn statement in proof of loss that Lyons submitted in December of 2010 sought $7.5 million, and the policyholder was estimating that the total cost of investigating and fixing the intrusion would top $11 million as of last year.

In the trial court, Lexington argued that it had suffered prejudice, and the District of Kansas agreed, granting the insurer’s motion for summary judgment.  On appeal, the Tenth Circuit assumed “that [Lyons] waited too long to notify Lexington,” but Judge Robert E. Bacharach nonetheless reversed, holding that Lexington had failed to show substantial prejudice.

Under Kansas law, an insurer can show prejudice by “presenting evidence that (1) its ability to investigate the claim has been lost; or (2) opportunities to negotiate settlement have been lost; or (3) opportunities to defend have been lost.”  According to the Court of Appeals, “to demonstrate prejudice, the insurer must show that it would have handled some aspect of the investigation, discovery or defense differently, and that with this change, [the insurer] could have either defeated the underlying claims or settled the underlying claims for a lower sum than for what the insureds settled.” Read more ›

About The Author
Tagged with:
Posted in Investigation, Notice, Water

Social Media — The Possibilities Are Endless!

Facebook.  Instagram.  YouTube.  Twitter.  LinkedIn.  SnapChat.  Flickr.  Google+.  Tumblr.   WeChat.  MySpace.  WhatsApp.  Reddit.  The list of social media and networking sites goes on and on.  It’s fairly common knowledge these days that a defendant can use social media and networking sites such as those  to investigate personal injury claimants.  In addition, more and more companies are using these types of sources to research potential employees.  You may be surprised to learn, however, that social media can be an extremely useful tool for the investigation of property damage and business interruption losses.shutterstock_134112389

Consider some scenarios:

An insured submits a claim for damage to a roof, asserting that it was the result  of a recent storm.  However, using the “Historical Imagery” capability of Google Earth (which allows you to see images from years ago), you learn that the damage to the roof pre-dated the storm.

An insured’s home is completely destroyed by fire, and the policyholder submits a list of contents.  Photographs taken inside the insured’s home during the holidays and at parties (taken or posted by either the insured herself or by her friends and family) prove that the actual contents of the residence are considerably  different than what she has alleged (e.g., there was a 47” flatscreen, not an 80” one).

An insured businessowner submits a claim for business interruption after his store is destroyed in an earthquake.  However, by tracking the insured’s Twitter, Google +, and Facebook statuses, posts and comments, you learn that the insured started selling his products  on-line shortly after the quake and has been steadily making half the amount of money he made with over-the-counter sales before the structure was leveled. Read more ›

About The Author
Tagged with:
Posted in Investigation

A New York Court Bars Coverage for a Power Outage Caused by Superstorm Sandy

This week saw a New York court bar a policyholder’s claim for business interruption occasioned by the loss of off-site power after Superstorm Sandy.  In Johnson Gallagher Magliery, LLC v. Charter Oak Fire Ins. Co., 2014 WL 1041831 (S.D.N.Y., March 18, 2014), the federal court held that a law firm could not recover for the six-day period during which one of Consolidated Edison’s networks was out-of-service.  The network was shut down preemptively several hours before the storm, and the contract of insurance’s “acts or decisions” exclusion was held to bar coverage for that period of time.  In addition, a “water” exclusion operated to preclude coverage for the time necessary to clean, repair, and re-energize the system after the flooding where “the only relevant evidence in the record” established that the sole cause of the damage was the excluded peril of water.

The policyholder was a Manhattan law firm with offices in a building on Wall Street.  The structure received electric power from Con Edison’s Bowling Green Network, which was a network that the utility had identified as susceptible to catastrophic failure should its equipment come into contact with salt water.  As Sandy approached on October 29, 2012, Con Edison preemptively shut down that network.

shutterstock_117450418Sandy struck several hours later, causing extensive flooding in lower Manhattan.  The Bowling Green Network suffered “extensive water damage” from the flooding, and Con Edison spent the next several days pumping out the water and cleaning, testing, and – as necessary – replacing its equipment.  The network was re-energized early in the morning on November 3.

The policyholder’s building did not receive electricity again until November 11, however, and the law firm was unable to return to its space until November 16.  In addition, telephone and internet service was not restored until January 7, 2013.

The policyholder had a business interruption insurance policy issued by Charter Oak Fire Insurance Company, and it made claim for business income lost during this two month period.  Charter Oak denied, and the firm brought suit in state court in New York.  After removal to the Southern District, Charter Oak filed a narrowly-focused motion for partial summary judgment, seeking to bar coverage for the power interruption between October 29 and November 11 on the basis of two exclusions. Read more ›

About The Author
Tagged with:
Posted in Acts or Decisions, Business Interuption, Direct Physical Loss or Damage, Flood, Superstorm Sandy

The House and Senate Vote to Roll Back National Flood Insurance Program Premium Increases

Congress has officially placed the bipartisan Homeowner Flood Insurance Affordability Act in hands of President Obama.  If enacted, it will undo significant provisions of a 2012 law that caused sharp flood insurance rate increases.

On March 4, the U.S. House of Representatives voted 306-91 to pass the Homeowner Flood Insurance Affordability Act of 2014, H.R. 3370.  This repeals portions of the Biggert-Waters Flood Insurance Reform Act.  Just yesterday, March 16, the U.S. Senate voted 72-22 to approve the bill and send it to the President for his consideration.

For those who don’t remember the Biggert-Waters Act, it was passed back in 2012 with overwhelming support in both houses of Congress.  It called for changes to the National Flood Insurance Program.  The NFIP, as you may know, is currently running an enormous and ultimately unsupportable deficit of $24 billion, so the Biggert-Waters Act aimed to eliminate subsidies for two kinds of homes: those homes built before flood maps existed and those homes “grandfathered” in, which is to say that they were originally built to code only to find that the new FEMA maps placed them in high-risk flood zones.  In doing so, Biggert-Waters caused steep rate increases for owners of these types of properties.  Homeowners in Florida, for example, saw annual flood insurance rate increases from $2,000 to $10,000 under the Biggert-Waters Act.

shutterstock_150004427In January, the Senate passed a bill which called for a four-year delay of the rate increases imposed by the Biggert-Waters.  House leaders, however, wanted a more permanent fix, and they also wanted to avoid adding to the insolvency of the NFIP.  Thus, the Homeowner Flood Insurance Affordability Act was born.  The bill proposes, among other things: (1) to roll back certain rate increase “triggers” so that policyholders will no longer face rate increases as a result of the sale of a home or a lapse in coverage;  (2) to provide a refund for those who already got hit under the foregoing  provisions;  (3) to restore “grandfathering” so that homes and businesses that were previously built to code and later remapped into a higher risk area by FEMA won’t face rate increases due to the remapping; and  (4) to impose a cap on FEMA’s ability to raise annual insurance premium rates.  Under the bill, FEMA can still increase premiums for owners of homes built before the flood insurance rate maps, but the increases have a hard cap of 18 percent per year (down from 20 percent under Biggert-Waters), and will typically range from only 5 percent to 15 percent.

President Obama is expected to sign the bill into law when it reaches his desk.

About The Author
Tagged with:
Posted in Flood, Flood Insurance

The Fourth Circuit Clarifies Who Is A Direct Supplier Under Contingent Business Interruption Coverage

In Millennium Inorganic Chemicals, Ltd. v. National Union Fire Ins. Co. et al., — F.3d. — , 2014 WL 642993 (4th Cir., Feb. 20, 2014), the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit recently clarified who constitutes a direct supplier of goods and services under contingent business interruption (CBI) insurance, and it specifically rejected arguments that the undefined term “direct” in the coverage grants of the CBI endorsements at issue was ambiguous in nature.

shutterstock_173639594The policyholder, Millennium Inorganic Chemicals, Ltd., processed titanium dioxide at its facility in Western Australia, using natural gas that it received via a pipeline.  It purchased the gas from Alinta Sales Pty Ltd., a retail gas supplier.  Alinta, in turn, purchased the gas it supplied to Millennium from others, including Apache Corporation.

Apache extracted and processed natural gas and then injected it into the pipeline, where it comingled with gas from other producers.  As soon as the substance was injected, custody, title, and risk for it passed to Alinta, and Apache had neither any ownership interest in the pipeline nor any contractual relationship with Millennium.

In 2008, an explosion shut down Apache’s facility, and the Australian government subsequently imposed controls, giving priority for delivery of the substance to essential services.  The result was that Millennium was forced to shut down for a number of months.

Millennium had CBI coverage with National Union Fire Insurance Company and ACE American Insurance Company.  The CBI endorsements in the two contracts of insurance provided Millennium with $10 million in coverage for “any unnamed direct contributing properties,” and they recited that only a “direct supplier of materials to the Insured’s locations” could be a “contributing property.” Read more ›

About The Author
Tagged with:
Posted in Ambiguity, Business Interuption, Contingent Business Interruption, Explosion

Federal Courts In New York and New Jersey Explore Streamlining Superstorm Sandy Discovery

Despite opposition by both many attorneys and the Federal Emergency Management Agency (“FEMA”), the federal court for the Eastern District of New York has now taken the first steps towards grouping some of the hundreds of pending Superstorm Sandy cases and expediting discovery in all of the them, and the District of New Jersey appears very likely to follow suit.

Superstorm Sandy is now officially the second most costly storm in United States history, having caused over $50 billion in damages, and one of the most heavily-impacted jurisdictions was the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York.  The Eastern District comprises Staten Island and all of Long Island, including the New York City boroughs of Brooklyn and Queens.  As of early February, over 800 Sandy cases were pending there against insurance carriers.  By contrast, less than half-a-dozen were in litigation in New York’s neighboring Southern District, which consists of Manhattan, the Bronx, the lower Hudson River valley.

shutterstock_158369090Faced with what she described as “an onslaught” of lawsuits, the district’s Chief Judge Carol Bagley Amon ordered the clerk to open a miscellaneous civil case captioned “In Re: Hurricane Sandy Cases,” Docket No. 14 MC 41, on January 10 “for the purposes of Pretrial Case Administration in all actions seeking insurance coverage for damage caused by Hurricane Sandy.”  She simultaneously directed three magistrate judges “to evaluate and make a recommendation regarding how to best handle all Hurricane Sandy cases.”

On January 14, the magistrates ordered counsel in all Superstorm Sandy matters that had been filed in the district’s two courthouses (Brooklyn and Central Islip) to submit schedules of their cases, identifying the parties, the properties, the judges assigned, and the “type of policy—wind damage, flood damage or both.”  The attorneys were also required to submit letters by January 24 setting forth their proposals with respect to how the court could logically group the matters for discovery and settlement purposes.  Finally, the panel scheduled a February conference to discuss counsel’s suggestions. Read more ›

About The Author
Tagged with: ,
Posted in Catastrophes, Superstorm Sandy, U.S. Legal System

New York’s Highest Court Holds a Two-Year Suit Limitation Provision Can Be Unenforceable

In answer to a question certified by the Second Circuit, New York Court of Appeals has held that a two-year suit limitation provision in a property insurance policy – which the court acknowledged was not an “inherently unreasonable” provision – was unenforceable under the factual circumstances of the case before it.  Executive Plaza, LLC v. Peerless Ins. Co., — N.Y.3d –, 2014 WL 551251, 2014 N.Y. LEXIS 165 (N.Y. Feb. 13, 2014).  In doing so, the court held for the first time that such a limitation period may be rendered unreasonable by what it called an inappropriate accrual date.

shutterstock_94679761Peerless Insurance Company issued a $1 million fire insurance policy to Executive Plaza.  This gave Executive the choice to select payment of “actual cash value” or payment of  “replacement cost.”  The policy also provided that Peerless would not pay the replacement cost for any loss or damage until the property had actually been repaired or replaced.  Finally, the policy contained a suit limitation clause that required the insured to commence any legal action within two years from the date of loss.

On February 23, 2007, Executive’s office building in Island Park, New York was severely damaged in a fire.  Peerless paid the actual cash value of the destroyed building, and Executive then notified the insurer that it would be making a replacement cost claim for the balance of the $1 million policy limit.  Peerless responded that Executive could only do so after providing “documentation verifying the completion of repairs.” Read more ›

About The Author
Tagged with:
Posted in Replacement Cost, Suit Limitation

Florida Property Manager’s Insurable Interest Is Limited To Its Fees

In Banta Properties, Inc. v. Arch Specialty, Ins. Co., —Fed.  Appx.— , 2014 WL 274478 (11th Cir., January 24, 2014), the Eleventh Circuit recently  held that a property manager’s insurable interest in the apartment complexes that it managed was limited to the income that it was entitled to receive under its contracts with the buildings’ owners.  Under Florida statutes, the measure of insurable interest is the loss that the policyholder might sustain from damage to the property, and that was held to preclude the property manager from asserting such an interest and recovering on its own behalf for the property damage that the apartments sustained from Hurricane Wilma.

shutterstock_111643277In October of 2005, Hurricane Wilma damaged three apartment complexes in Broward County, Florida.  The property manager for all three was Banta Properties, Inc., a company owned by various Banta family members.  The individual family members also owned two of the three properties at the time of the storm, having sold the third one (Parkcrest Apartments) to an unrelated, non-party entity two months beforehand.

Banta Properties was the named insured under a primary, $2.5 million commercial property policy from General Star Insurance Company.  The defendant, Arch Specialty, provided $8.5 million in excess property coverage, and both carriers’ contracts of insurance listed the three complexes as additional named insureds. Read more ›

About The Author
Tagged with:
Posted in Additional Insureds, Hurricane, Insurable Interest

Wisconsin Adds “Septage” To The List Of Substances Deemed To Be Pollutants

In Preisler v. Kuettel’s Septic Service, LLC, et al., 2014 WL 114325 (Wisc.App., Jan. 14, 2014), the intermediate level of appellate court in Wisconsin recently held that “septage” – a combination of water, urine, feces, and chemicals that is used as a fertilizer – was “unambiguously a pollutant.”  The case involved the scope of comprehensive general liability (“CGL”) coverage, but the CGL policy exclusions at issue were virtually identical to pollution exclusions commonly found in first-party contracts of insurance.  The decision is important to property carriers as a result, and it also rejects a number of arguments that first-party insureds frequently make in an effort to limit or avoid the application of such language.

shutterstock_102263728The Preislers owned a dairy farm with cattle, and they used a well to stock a pool on the property.  For several years, they had defendant Kuettel’s Septic spray several thousand gallons of septage on their farmland.  Kuettel’s Septic was in the business of removing, hauling, storing and disposing of the substance, which comes from septic tanks, grease traps, floor pits, and car washes.  It is disposed of by either taking it to a treatment facility or by spreading it on farmland as a fertilizer.  It contains high levels of nitrogen.

In 2008, a large algae bloom appeared in the Preislers’ pool and their cattle began to die.  Tests subsequently showed that the septage had caused an elevated nitrate level in the well water.  The Preislers drilled a new well and then brought suit against Kuettel’s Septic and its CGL carriers, alleging private nuisance, trespass and strict liability and tort.  The insurers asserted that pollution exclusions in their policies barred coverage, and both the Circuit Court and the Wisconsin Court of Appeals agreed.

The contracts of insurance all excluded damage caused by the actual, alleged or threatened discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release or escape of pollutants.  In addition, they all defined the term “pollutant” to mean any solid, liquid, gaseous, or thermal irritant or contaminant including smoke, vapor, soot, fumes, acids, alkalines, chemicals and waste.  The appellate court had no difficulty in concluding that septage was “a contaminant, an irritant, and a waste substance” and, therefore, fell within the ambit of the exclusionary language. Read more ›

About The Author
Tagged with: ,
Posted in Efficient Proximate Cause, Exclusions, Pollution, Reasonable Expectations

Saving Green by Going Green

As Kermit the Frog famously said: “It’s not easy being green.”  When it comes to property insurance, Kermit is only partially correct.  Although green buildings and commercial construction projects pose unique risks that are likely not covered by traditional commercial property policies, the insurance industry has become increasingly responsive to this issue by creating and offering products specifically tailored for green risks.

Just What is Green Construction, Anyway?

Green construction (also known as a “green building” or a “sustainable building”) is an environmentally responsible and resource efficient structure and process.  In other words, it’s not just the building itself that’s “green” – it’s the entire construction and using process.

The objective of green construction is to reduce the overall impact of the built environment on human health and the natural environment.  To do so, there is an emphasis on, among other things:

  • Energy efficiency – reducing operating energy use through high-performance windows, passive solar design, and on-site generation of renewable energy;
  • Materials efficiency – utilizing recycled materials, rapidly renewable plant resources, and locally extracted and manufactured building materials to minimize energy expended their transport;
  • Indoor environmental quality (“IEQ”) – reducing volatile organic compounds in the air, maintaining an efficient ventilation system, and controlling moisture accumulation; and
  • Waste reduction – providing on-site compost bins to reduce the amount of occupant-generated matter which is hauled to a landfill, and innovative processes such as using “greywater” (water from, e.g., dishwashers and washing machines) or rainwater for subsurface irrigation and flushing toilets.

Why “Go Green”?

There are a variety of incentives for “going green.”  The environmental incentives are perhaps the most obvious: conserving natural resources, improving air and water quality, enhancing and protecting ecosystems and biodiversity, and reducing all the bad stuff (e.g., solid waste, greenhouse gas emissions, and the dreaded carbon footprint).  There are also social incentives, like increasing the respect and strength of a brand and positively impacting the health and social well-being of the building’s occupants.

shutterstock_140934022Of course, when we’re dealing with commercial construction and property insurance, the most significant incentive for “going green” is probably economic.  Over time, green buildings can reduce operating costs, improve employee productivity and satisfaction (a happy employee is a productive employee!), enhance asset value and profits, generate a better return on the owner’s investment (e.g., higher rents, sales prices and occupancy rates), reduce liability risks, and optimize the performance of a building during its life-cycle.  There are also federal, state or local tax incentives for certain types of green construction.

There can be a conflict between the “up-front” cost and the “life-cycle” cost, as green buildings can be more expensive to construct due to, for example, the novelty of the construction process or the use of certain less common materials.  In time, the “up-front” outlay is likely to be outweighed by the building’s “life-cycle” cost.  Take-away: green construction will likely generate a greater investment return than traditional construction. Read more ›

About The Author
Posted in Business Interuption, Green Insurance, Replacement Cost
About The Property Insurance Law Observer

For more than five decades, Cozen O’Connor has represented all types of property insurers in jurisdictions throughout the United States, and it is dedicated to keeping its clients abreast of developments that impact the insurance industry. The Property Insurance Law Observer will survey court decisions, enacted or proposed legislation, and regulatory activities from all 50 states. We will also include commentary on current issues and developing trends of interest to first-party insurers.

Subscribe For Updates

propertyinsurancelawobserver

Archives
Topics
Cozen O’Connor Blogs