In March we ran a post on how important videos, photographs, and statements on social media sites can be when investigating a property loss. A picture is literally worth a thousand words. Earlier this month, a Florida court explained that such material is also discoverable – even in situations where the policyholder employs privacy settings that prevent the general public from having access to his or her account – because the user’s privacy interest in such a site is “minimal, if any.” Nucci v. Target Corp., – So.3d –, 2015 WL 71726, 2015 Fla. App. LEXIS 153 (Fla.Dist.Ct.App., Jan. 7, 2015) involved a slip-and-fall, but it applies with equal force to discovery in a first-party matter.
Maria Nucci filed a personal injury action against Target, alleging that she fell on “a foreign substance” on the floor of one of the defendant’s stores. Her complaint contended that she sustained permanent injuries, aggravated pre-existing ones, and also experienced lost earnings and emotional pain and suffering. Prior to her deposition, Target’s attorneys reviewed her Facebook profile and found that it contained 1,285 photographs. She was questioned about some of them at the deposition itself, and she promptly took three dozen of the pictures down.
Target moved to compel. After a hearing, the trial court ordered production of “copies or screenshots of all photographs associated with” any social networking account that Ms. Nucci was currently registered with from two years prior to the date of loss until the present. The plaintiff then sought certiorari review from Florida’s intermediate level appellate court. Read more ›

The policyholders owned a gas station and convenience store in Cherry Hill, New Jersey. The structure experienced moderate damage during a storm on August 14, 2011. Two weeks later on August 28th, the rear portion of the building collapsed during Hurricane Irene. There was a 72” corrugated metal culvert running underground near the rear of the structure, and this was corroded and decayed. Experts for both sides agreed that the deteriorated culvert sustained damage during the first storm and then partially collapsed after Irene, leading to extensive soil erosion; when the insurer’s expert examined the property two days after the storm, there was a hole 60’ long, 20’ wide, and 8’ deep behind the building.
(1) A man who fell asleep during Red Sox game at Yankee Stadium filed a lawsuit against ESPN and its announcers as well as Major League Baseball and the Yankees after he was shown napping on a live telecast of the game. According to his complaint, he suffered “substantial injury” to his “character and reputation” and “mental anguish, loss of future income and loss of earning capacity” as a result of the incident. His complaint seeks $10 million in damages.
Congress has a bad habit of larding important legislation like TRIA with wholly-unrelated provisions, and it was one of those that doomed reauthorization. When the Senate wrote its own reauthorization bill earlier this year, it proposed including a provision creating the National Association of Registered Agents and Brokers (NARAB), a non-profit clearinghouse made up of state insurance commissioners and insurance market representatives which would oversee and streamline the licensing of agents and brokers. Senator Tom Coburn (R-Okla.) was opposed, believing that to be a federal infringement on authority traditionally reserved for the individual states, and the Senate bill that was sent to the House on July 17th sunset NARAB after two years.
The House of Representatives’ Financial Services Committee sent a reauthorization bill to the House floor on June 20th, but it was never voted on by the full chamber. It had been passed out of the committee on a partisan 32-27 vote, and its sponsors evidently felt that it reduced the federal government’s backstop role too drastically to have any chance of passing the Senate. The upper chamber then passed a reauthorization bill of its own on July 17th by a 93-4 vote and sent it to the House, but it languished there until recently as TRIA’s expiration date grew ever closer.
Alfredo Mejia owned a home that was insured by Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, and he made a claim for damage, contending that it was caused by sinkhole activity. The insurer retained BCI, an engineering firm, and it denied liability after BCI concluded that the damage was not caused by a sinkhole. A breach of contract action followed.
Gregory Packaging manufactured and sold juice cups, and it was in the process of installing a refrigeration system at a new plant in Newman, Georgia when anhydrous ammonia was accidentally released into the facility, severely burning a subcontract worker. The plant was evacuated, and a remediation company was retained to dissipate the gas. That process took several days.
G & S Metal Consultants filed suit for property damage and business interruption loss after a steam explosion at a Georgia facility. After discovery was complete, the insurer, Continental Casualty, successfully sought permission to file an amended answer asserting additional affirmative defenses and a counterclaim based on alleged misconduct by G & S during the claim adjustment process that it had allegedly learned of during discovery, and the court reopened discovery to allow the policyholder to defend against the counterclaim. The insured then sought to question the carrier’s 30(b)(6) designee about reserves, and it filed a motion to compel after Continental’s attorneys objected to that line of questioning.
The Strausses had constructed a home in Mequon, Wisconsin in 1994, and they were insured by four separate Chubb carriers from then until October of 2005. In October of 2010, Mr. and Mrs. Strauss discovered that a defect during construction in 1994 had been allowing water infiltration during every rainstorm over the past 16 years, causing damage to the building’s envelope. They made claim under the 1994-2005 Chubb policies, but the insurers denied liability, and the Strausses brought suit in federal court in October of 2011, within one year of their discovery of the damage.