Business interruption losses after a catastrophic event often implicate overlapping causes, and a recent North Carolina decision demonstrates that even a broad conception of direct physical loss does not displace clear exclusionary language in a commercial property policy. In East Fork Pottery, LLC v. The Phoenix Insurance Company, 2026 WL 3409050 (W.D.N.C. Nov. 10, 2026), the Western District of North Carolina held that the Utility Services exclusion, reinforced by anti-concurrent causation language, barred coverage for Business Income losses following Hurricane Helene where an off-premises utility failure contributed to East Fork’s suspension of operations. The court also rejected East Fork’s unfair and deceptive trade practices claim, despite acknowledging that Phoenix’s denial letters were “not the model of clarity.” Together, these holdings define the limits of coverage when an excluded cause contributes to a multi-cause loss and draw an important line between an imperfect coverage explanation and one that can support a separate claim for unfair or deceptive claim handling.
East Fork operated several locations in Asheville, several of which lost utility service after Hurricane Helene and remained closed for more than two weeks. Although multiple storm-related conditions contributed to the shutdown, the record established that off-premises utility damage was one contributing cause and fell within the Utility Services exclusion for loss caused directly or indirectly by an off-premises failure of power, water, or another utility service. Because the exclusion applied regardless of any other cause contributing concurrently or in sequence to the loss, the off-premises utility failure was sufficient to bar coverage notwithstanding the other conditions that contributed to the suspension of operations.
Relying, however, on North State Deli, LLC v. Cincinnati Insurance Co., East Fork argued that the resulting loss of use amounted to direct physical loss and fell within the exception for a utility failure that “results in a Covered Cause of Loss.” The court disagreed and explained that the exception requires the utility failure to produce a separate Covered Cause of Loss, which must then, in turn, cause the claimed loss or damage. Without evidence that the off-premises power failure produced that separate Covered Cause of Loss, the exception could not restore coverage for the resulting Business Income loss. A broader reading would allow the exception to restore coverage for Business Income loss attributable to the same off-premises utility failure that the exclusion otherwise precludes from coverage.
The court also considered whether Phoenix adequately explained the basis for denying coverage under North Carolina’s Unfair and Deceptive Trade Practices Act. While the denial letters did not cite the Utility Services exclusion, Phoenix consistently explained that off-premises utility damage was the basis for denying Business Income coverage. Unlike DENC, LLC v. Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Co., where the insurer relied on superseded and inapplicable policy provisions without adequately explaining why coverage was unavailable, the court concluded that the denial letters here, though “not the model of clarity,” did not have the same capacity to mislead.
Viewed more broadly, East Fork Pottery places an important limit on the reach of North State Deli in claims involving an excluded cause of loss. Where an exception requires the excluded event to produce a separate Covered Cause of Loss that, in turn, causes the claimed loss or damage, the insured must present evidence establishing that causal sequence before the exception can restore coverage. As the court explained, merely characterizing the resulting loss of use as direct physical loss is not sufficient without evidence that the excluded event actually produced the separate Covered Cause of Loss required by the exception. The decision also confirms that an imperfect denial does not necessarily support a UDTPA claim where the insurer consistently communicates the factual basis for its coverage determination.